I also had an issue with the judging system early in the game. I was set to 90% accuracy and 10% damage. Completely dominated the fight, stayed on the outside and worked the jab. However, ever since I made damage a bit larger 40-60% it makes a big difference. Hopefully that'll work for you. Needless to say, try to set your fighters to finish the opponent, then this problem won't occur!!! (I realize this is hard, but if you set tactics and game plan based on your opponents weaknesses it makes it a lot easier!) - This is one of the most valuable skills I find!